Tonys N.Y. Pizza @ The Forum

theresa henriksen 5 months ago

FIRST & LAST time here! I had a $90 take out order. I ordered chicken parm with spaghetti pasta. When I got home and opened it, they gave me penne pasta instead. I called the restaurant and they put the owner on the phone. He said “ what you don’t like penne pasta? I’ll give you a $5 credit the next time you come in.” Bad business, I didn’t get what I ordered. Check out the penne pasta, they don’t even give you pasta sauce! Totally horrible.

Arzu Pajotte 6 months ago

We came to try the pizza because we’d heard it was one of the best in Lee Count qnd it absolutely lived up to the hype. We ordered a Margherita pizza with half Hawaiian. I’m usually not a fan of Hawaiian, but the kids wanted it, and, it was actually delicious. We also tried the Nutella calzone, and it was 100/10. We’ll be coming back.

Amy 6 months ago

We are from out of town but my husband is Italian so you know how that goes! Gotta find a good New York style pizza place. From the minute you walk in you can smell the garlic. The service is friendly and fast. The owner kept walking around asking people if everything was OK, checking to make sure tasks were done, even delivering food to customers if wait staff was busy, etc., great attention to detail. The kitchen is right here where you can see food being prepared as you’re ordering. Not only does the place smell delicious but the food is scrumptious! We ordered the Madison Square Garden veggie pizza and it was incredible. All fresh ingredients, sliced tomato, onions, mushrooms, black, olives, and fresh basil, very tasty. Definitely exceeded our expectations and lives up to the name, New York pizza!

Olivia Nguyen 6 months ago

Tony’s NY Pizza was absolutely amazing! From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere felt welcoming and authentic. The pizza was incredible — perfectly crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and generous toppings. You can really tell they care about quality. Our server, Sandy, made the experience even better. She was friendly, attentive, and made sure everything was perfect throughout our visit. Great service like that makes a huge difference! If you’re looking for great New York-style pizza with excellent service, Tony’s is definitely the place to go. We’ll definitely be coming back!

hunter reeves Edited 7 months ago

Tony’s is our favorite pizza place down here. We visit at least once a week and have never had a bad meal. The variety is perfect for our little family.